Is Deep Breathing Yoga's Secret Sauce?

-
When people speak about Yoga and its feel-good properties, they often suggest that slow, deep breathing is the reason that Yoga often feels good. While I cannot deny that an awareness or modification of breathing is indeed a defining characteristic of Modern Postural Yoga, I'm not convinced that Yoga's benefits are all about the breathing. Yes, the breathing's effect on the nervous system may be what makes us feel good after a Yoga practice, though it may turn out that Yoga stimulates the endocannabinoid system, increases the activity of the paraventricular hypothalamus (and stimulates the release of oxytocin), or activates another of the various feel-good systems that are embedded within the human body. I sure don't know, and I'm not sure that anyone fully understands why Yoga feels good.
Buddy's vagal tone (and heart rate variability) appear
to be elevated.
What do we know about slow, deep breathing? In a Yogic interpretation of the Polyvagal Theory, proponents suggest that deep breathing increases Heart Rate Variability (HRV). HRV, in turn,  has been shown to correlate with greater activity in the parasympathetic branch of the autonomic nervous system. Voila: deep breathing = increased parasympathetic activity = greater HRV = enhanced rest and recovery = feeling good.

 There's only one detail problem - the relationship between deep breathing, HRV and vagal tone is an imperfect one. Below is a quote from a highly regarded academic paper by Grossman and Taylor:

 Alterations in respiration rate and tidal volume had profound effects upon RSA magnitude that were unrelated to directly determined levels of cardiac vagal tone.
(from: Grossman, P., and; Taylor, E. W. (2007). Toward understanding respiratory sinus arrhythmia: relations to cardiac vagal tone, evolution and biobehavioral functions. Biological psychology, 74(2), 263-285.)

 What does this mean? It means that HRV and vagus activity are strongly correlated... except when the breathing is altered. In the case of slow, deep breathing, the measures of HRV and vagal tone decouple. Yes, deep breathing can increase HRV, though this increased HRV doesn't necessarily translate into moving the proverbial needle from fight/flight/freeze to rest and digest. Because of the strength of the evidence supporting Grossman and Taylor's statement, some scientists consider HRV a measure of vagal tone only if the rate and depth of breathing is controlled for within a study.

 This posting has gotten a bit technical, so I'd like to summarize its thoughts in the following bullet points:
  • Slow, deep breathing is a part of many Yogic traditions
    • HRV is a validated measure of vagal tone (relaxation response)
  • Slow, deep breathing increases HRV
  • HRV and vagal tone decouple in the presence of deep breathing
  • The upshot; claims that slow, deep breathing causes the relaxation and/or feel-good response are not necessarily supported by the Polyvagal Theory
As a result, claims that slow, deep breathing causes this, that or the other thing in Yoga may end up validated in the future, though at current time, the evidence is inconclusive.

Comments

Bill Baudhuin said…
This is a very interesting topic. I have taken my HRV score via a couple of different smart phone apps pretty regularly. I find HRV to be pretty consistent over a long period of time, however there are certain behaviors I can do to momentarily increase my HIV score, e.g.,cold water in my face, yawning. I continue to be fascinated by HRV and its application to resiliency and rest and recovery for cardiovascular conditioning. Thanks for the great article.
May 6, 2019 at 5:46 AM
Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

You have lots of... things

-
Image
The hearse pulled into my family’s driveway at the appointed hour. My parents mentioned that an artist was stopping by, though I had no idea the artist’s entrance would imprint so indelibly in my mind. From his ginormous, black hearse, to the wild hair and beard, this man-in-black was the antithesis of the early-1970s, suburban world that I inhabited. My adoptive parents were thoroughly suburban. We had lots of stuff, and hungered for the stuff that we didn’t have. I thought nothing of this – it’s how all my friends and I lived. With one sentence, however, the artist showed me another view of all this stuff, initiating a conflicted relationship with stuff that I’ve been working with for 50+ years. Repurposed hearses are really big station wagons that can haul lots of things. As he entered our house, he hesitantly said “You have lots of… things .” The pause on “things” was pregnant with meaning, and even though I was scarcely of school-age, I grokked the layered meanings implied by the
Read more

Sweets and Your Mitochondria

-
Image
The vitality of your cellular mitochondria are a significant predictor of your health. To support your overall health, it's best to avoid low-fiber foods that are sweet. Fruit is sweet, though is generally high in fiber. A donut, on the other hand, is low in fiber and sweet. The metabolic pathways of each are significantly different, and interact with enzymes in your liver in very different ways. This plant-based donut did not check the whole-foods box Metabolic health is your mitochondria working at peak efficiency, and your liver is a mitochondria factory. When you eat low-fiber foods that are sweet, the AMP-activated protein kinase (AMPK) in your liver isn't able to bond with the receptors that initiate the production of healthy mitochondria. While your tissues may be crying out for refreshed mitochondria, the factory doors are locked when you consume low-fiber, sweet food. Not all sweet food is created equal - there are many types of sugars, such as sucrose, fructose, lac
Read more

Worklife Bardo

-
Image
  I’m currently parked in a Bardo. What, you may ask, is a Bardo? According to meditation teacher Andrew Holecek, the Tibetan word “Bardo” is translated as “gap, interval, intermediate state, transition process or in between…” The next chapter of life has yet to be written, and the final page of the previous chapter has been turned. Last month I graduated – a milestone I eagerly anticipated since my first day of grad school, nearly seven years ago. While I (mostly) appreciated the process of earning the Ph.D., I never lost sight of the goal. I was not in grad school for the sake of being in grad school – I consistently had a sense of purpose… almost a mission. Interestingly, that mission took multiple twists and turns throughout the duration of the process. Now that the final page on the grad-school chapter has been turned, the first pages of the next chapter aren’t what I expected. The various twists and turns appeared to lead into a long hallway. Like MIT’s Infinite Corridor , this h
Read more